Reviews

Best Electric Turkey Roasters – Consumer Reports

If you are preparing for a feast of full turkey on holiday you will have to invest hours to cook. Having an electric roaster will save your time. Electric turkey roasters can provide great large meals for six, eight, or ten guests at a time.

Roaster ovens are an excellent addition to any kitchen arsenal. If you are worried about the limitation of stationary kitchen appliances roaster ovens are here to save you as these are completely portable.

Best Electric Turkey Roasters 2022

There are several options for the best turkey roasters in the market now. Let’s go through this shortlist and get to know the best electric turkey roasters.

Image

Product

Features

Price

Best Electric Turkey Roasters

Oster Roaster Oven

The lid is self-basting

Enamel-on-steel roasting pan

Up to 26lbs

$$$

Hamilton Beach Roaster Oven

Handles for safety

Removable insert pot

Self-basting lid

$$$

Best Electric Turkey Roasters

Heynemo Electric Roaster Oven

Ideal temperature until serving

Large multi-function roaster oven

self-basting lid

$$

Nesco Classic Roaster Oven

Energy-efficient system

Porcelain-coated surface

Provides 18-quart cooking option

$$$

Best Electric Turkey Roasters

Proctor Silex Roaster Oven

The temperature range is 150 to 400 degrees

Easy cleanup

High dome design

$$

Generic Electric Roaster Oven

Safety handles

Offers a variable temperature range

The lid is self-busting

$$

Best Electric Turkey Roasters

Sunvivi 18-Quart Electric Roaster

Easy cleanup

Keep the food fresh

Continually recirculate moisture

$$

Hamilton Beach Slow Cooker

Versatile cooking options

Safety side handles

10-quart capacity and 10lbs of turkey

$$$

Best Electric Turkey Roasters

Nesco Classic Roaster Oven

Provides an extra high dome

Self-busting lid

Comes with an indicating light

$$

Rival Roaster Oven

Removable steel rack and pan

Perfect heat distribution

Versatile roaster oven

$$


Oster Roaster Oven

If you are planning to make a Thanksgiving dinner for your family or friends this electric roaster is here to save the day. This oven offers plenty of helpful features. There is a total of 14 heat settings so that you can adjust make the meal your own choice. There is also a defrost setting for your frozen food.

The space this roaster provides is amazing. You can also fit some extra vegetables with the turkey. This extra storage is really helpful when you want to make the best home-cooked meal.

PROS:

  • Accommodates turkeys up to 26lbs.
  • The lid is self-basting.
  • Enamel-on-steel roasting pan.

CONS:

  • This roaster is not appropriate if you want to save kitchen storage space.

Hamilton Beach Roaster Oven

If you are looking forward to a big family dinner or a celebration, having some extra capacity for cooking helps. Heynemo introduced this amazing model with a 24-quart capacity roasting pan. This pan is big enough to roast a whole turkey and you can fill up the extra space with some vegetables.

The size is not the only feature this oven offers. It also allows you 14 different settings with temperature control from 150 degrees to 450 degrees. You can also use this oven to cook other dishes.

The cleanup process of this oven is also easy and fast. The inner pan is removable so that you can remove and clean it after cooking. The exterior of the oven is made of stainless steel which protects this from getting dirty.

PROS:

  • Comes with a self-basting lid.
  • Comes with a removable insert pot.
  • Cool-touch handles for safety.

CONS:

  • The quality of the wire is not so good.

Heynemo Electric Roaster Oven

If you are looking forward to a big family dinner or a celebration, having some extra capacity for cooking really helps. Heynemo introduced this amazing model with 24-quart capacity roasting pan. This pan is big enough to roast a whole turkey and you can fill up the extra space with some vegetables.

The size is not the only feature this oven offers. It also allows you 14 different settings with the temperature control from 150 degrees to 450 degrees. You can also use this oven to cook other dishes.

PROS:

  • Comes with a self-basting lid.
  • Comes with a removable insert pot.
  • Cool-touch handles for safety.

CONS:

  • These ovens are quite heavy. Not easy to transport.

Nesco Classic Roaster Oven

If you are looking for something smaller than this oven is the perfect one for you. This is a lightweight roaster with a big 18-quart option. You can cook a turkey up to 22lbs in this roaster. There is a removable steel rack that comes with the oven. The handle of the steel rack can be used to lift out the food. You can adjust the temperature from 200 to 450 degrees.

Nesco claims to save energy for their “Circle of Heat” element.  So it makes this roaster very energy-efficient. The surface of the roaster is porcelain-coated which fights against scratches, stains, and corrosion.

PROS:

  • Provides 18-quart cooking option.
  • Porcelain-coated surface.
  • Energy-efficient system.

CONS:

  • Not suitable to cook large meals.

Proctor Silex Roaster Oven

Here is a great small-sized roaster oven with a compact design. This electric roaster is small but it is no behind when it comes to innovative features. There is an adjustable temperature range from 150 to 400 degrees which allows you to cook as per your need. You can not only cook a turkey but also cook various dishes like chicken, ham, cake, and dessert.

The cleanup system of this roaster is very easy. You can easily remove the steel pan and clean it without any inconvenience. This roaster also comes with a one-year warranty.

PROS:

  • Compact and extra high dome design.
  • Comes with 2 cool-touch handles for safety.
  • The steel pan is removable for easy cleanup.

CONS:

  • The temperature may cause a problem for some users.

Generic Electric Roaster Oven

If you are looking for a simple electric roaster oven that is loaded with all the features then Generic is here for you. With a large holding capacity of 22-quart, this roaster can cook up to 22lbs of turkey. It offers an adjustable temperature range for your desired cooking result.

The features of this roaster are innovative and people are impressed by this roaster. This roaster is easy to use and easy to clean up. Great for new chefs.

PROS:

  • Offers a variable temperature range.
  • Comes with a removable roasting pan.
  • The lid is self-busting.

CONS:

  • This oven is relatively overpriced.

Sunvivi 18-Quart Electric Roaster

If there is a shortage of space in your kitchen let’s go for this portable and compact electric roaster. The design of this roaster is compact but still, they offer a good enough space of 18-quarts. You can bake, roast, boil, and cook in this roaster. This roaster will give you your desired result on the table.

There are many innovative features in this roaster. You can set from a variable temperature setting. There is also a “keep warm” function which retains the heat. This option will keep your food fresh and warm until serving.

PROS:

  • The self-busting lid will continually recirculate moisture.
  • Comes with a warming setting to keep the food fresh.
  • Easy cleanup.

CONS:

  • The durability of this oven is not impressive.

Hamilton Beach Slow Cooker

As you know Hamilton is one of the greatest brands when it comes to electric roasters. If you like the features you should go for Hamilton blindly. This electric roaster will give you three temperatures setting. It also offers you various cooking options. Whether you are making a Thanksgiving dinner or a picnic meal you can do that with this roaster.

The cleanup process of this roaster is also pretty easy. The roaster ensures an easy cleanup for you.

PROS:

  • 10-quart capacity and 10lbs of turkey.
  • Removable pan for easy cleanup.
  • Safety side handles.

CONS:

  • Quite expensive

Nesco Classic Roaster Oven

If you are into roasters that will give you great innovative features with a classic and elegant look then Nesco is here to save the day. You can cook your food at various heat settings and get your desired textured food.

There is a temperature setting from 200 to 450 degrees. You can cook the food in minutes with this model. There is also an indicator light for safety purposes. This roaster is dishwasher-safe.

PROS:

  • Offers adjustable temperature from 200 to 450 degrees.
  • Provides an extra high dome.
  • Self-busting lid.

CONS:

  • Not suitable for cooking big meals.

Rival Roaster Oven

If you are looking for a roaster for cooking at holiday parties or a get-together then this is a perfect roaster for you.  This roaster offers you from 150 to 450 degrees temperature setting. You can fit up to 22lbs of turkey. The steel rack and pan of this roaster are removable for easy cleanup.

Overall this a pretty good roaster with affordable price ranges. You can purchase it for the holiday season.

PROS:

  • Versatile roaster oven.
  • Accommodates roasts up to 22lbs.
  • Removable steel rack and pan.

CONS:

  • Sometimes the roaster leaks after cooking.

Electric Turkey Roaster Buying Guide

The best electric turkey roaster will come with some innovative features. Let’s go through some features you need to look at when you are purchasing a new one.

Size & Capacity

This feature depends on the purpose of purchasing. If you are buying a roaster large enough to feed eight to ten people then buying an 18-quart roaster will be a good start. But for the holiday seasons and parties, you need to go for more capacity.

Material

This feature is important to look over as you will need to clean the roaster after you cook. The cleanup process depends on the material of the roaster. Stainless steel has more advantages than enameled steel. Such as these are a bit more lightweight so it’s easy to transport and carry.

Lid

The lid is an important feature of a roaster. The lid keeps the roaster easy to clean and it’s durable and good at retaining heat. You can go for a high-dome lid as they will allow you to fit a large turkey without the meat contacting the lid.

Temperature

You need to go for a simple on/off dial and a great temperature range for you. Many roasters also come with a ‘keep warm’ option which allows you to keep the meal warm until serving. You can also go for a defrost setting.

Cleaning and Maintenance

Material has a lot of roles to play when it comes to cleaning. You need to go for those roasters which offer removable pans and steel rack. Those are always a great choice.

Final Thoughts

A roaster oven is a great addition to your kitchen. Whenever you are preparing meals for the holidays these roasters will save a lot of your time. If you want a delicious home-cooked meal then roasters will provide you with that.

With that being said, all the roasters featured in this article come with great innovative features. So let’s purchase the best electric roaster and make a delicious meal.

You may also like to read: Best Tabletop Grills