Best Pellet Stove – Consumer Reports

If you are trying to keep yourself warm during the cold winter and the chilly days that just come around throughout the year, your best and most efficient bet would be a pellet stove. Pellet stoves are cheap to run, environment friendly and also safe.

They are gaining quite the popularity in recent times since they provide you with a much affordable way of warming up your house or just a single room even.

Best Pellet Stoves in 2022

The number of choices and options you have when you start looking can make the process of buying one a bit intimidating. To help you out with that, we went ahead and chose some of the best ones out there that you can get your hands on.

Image Product Features Price
Pellet Stove Comfortbilt HP22

86% thermal efficiency

Programmable thermostat

Provides a 1 year parts warranty

Castle Serenity Stove 12327

Thermal efficiency is at least 69.8%

Comes with a smart controller

Operates at 77 watts

Pellet Stove Pelpro PP130-B

Is EPA certified

Offers you easy to use controls

The fire pot empties itself

Vogelzang VG5790

The thermostat has LED display

Has an air wash glass

200 CFM

Pellet Stove US Stove Company US GW1949

Has an EPA certification

Operates in silence

Has a modern design

U S Stove Company 5510

Has an ash pan

Offers easy cleaning

Has a LED display for easy use


Comfortbilt HP22

This pellet stove by Comfortbilt features one of the largest viewing windows that you can find in pellet stoves. The HP22 is sure to bring a great atmosphere to any room. It offers you all the efficiency and benefits of a pellet stove while maintaining a good old fashioned wood heater look.

This pellet stove comes with an amazing efficiency rating of 86%, making it an ideal choice for larger homes since it also offers a heating capacity of up to about 3000 square foot.

Another thing that we found with this unit is the fan sound, it operates really quietly and is a great choice for people who can’t stand loud fans and find them to be annoying.

One thing that you should keep in mind is that compared to the heating capacity, this pellet stove has a relatively small hopper, which you can however easily fix by getting a cheap hopper extension.


  • Comes with a 3000 square feet heating capacity
  • Allows a maximum burn time of up to 24 hours
  • 43000 max BTU/hour output


  • Has a rather small hopper

Castle Serenity Stove 12327

If you’re only looking for a heater that can keep smaller areas like a shed or a cabin warm then there’s no real reason for you to go buy something extremely powerful or really big, going with the Castle Serenity Stove 12327 will be the ideal choice for you.

It has a small and compact design to make sure it doesn’t take up a lot of space in small areas while giving you a heating capacity of around 1500 square feet.

To make warming up as simple as it can possibly be, this pellet stove comes with a smart controller, which lets you select manual, weekly or thermostat operational modes and also offers you five separate burning levels.

If you forget to program it to switch on automatically you have nothing to worry about since this pellet stove can start pumping full heat in just 10 minutes whereas most others take at least 15 to 20 minutes.

They also have great customer service to help you with any problems, no matter how simple or technical.


  • It is easy to maintain and clean
  • Five levels of fire burn
  • Offers an attractive design


  • It is quite expensive

Pelpro PP130

If your first and most important requirement is efficiency from a pellet stove then you should definitely take a look at the Pelpro PP130. This pellet stove by Pelpro boasts an 87.5% EPA certified efficiency, making it one of the most efficient and best pellet stoves that you can get your hands on.

It doesn’t just give you efficiency; it is also a great choice for houses and areas ranging from medium to large with its 2500 square feet heating capacity.

You can easily set the level of heat you need with the easy-to-use and simple dial control on the side of the unit. This pellet stove gives you up to 4 days of burn time with its massive 130 Ilb hopper.


  • You get 87.5% thermal efficiency
  • Provides a ton of burn time
  • Gives you 40600 BTU output


  • The customer service isn’t the best

Vogelzang VG5790

This pellet stove by Vogelzang comes with a hopper that offers you a maximum capacity of about 120 pounds of pellets and it is also a fully automatic option.

The VG5790 is a pellet stove that is very simple and easy to use because of its electric controls and it can also be hooked up to your thermostat in no time.

It offers you a total of up to 60 hours of burn time with its big hopper capacity. It’s a great choice for houses since it comes with a heating capacity of 2800 square feet.


  • Has a 120 pound hopper
  • Offers a modern and durable design
  • Comes with electronic controls


  • It is rather loud

US Stove Company US GW1949

If you’re out looking for something that has the best design and will make a great attraction to your living room then this is definitely the one.

The GW1949 comes with a really unique design and ensures less work for you since it relies on a natural gravity feed system.

It has a 60 pound hopper and it can easily heat up to 2000 square feet with its 40000 BTUs. It also offers a pretty quiet operation.


  • Has around 36 hours of burn time
  • Holds up to 60 pounds of pellets
  • Requires less maintenance


  • It is a bit pricey

U S Stove Company 5510

This pellet stove comes with a 140 pound pellet hopper that can give you days’ worth of burn time It offers adjustable controls and nine different heat settings with an output of 48000 BTU.

It doesn’t come with a thermostat but it is however compatible with most available wall thermostats. It can be used as the primary heat source is most houses since it gives you a heat capacity of up to 1200 square feet.

For extended operation and easy cleaning between shutdowns, it comes with clean outs and an ash pan. Easy to use with the LED display and it also features a built in diagnostics.


  • 1200 square feet heat capacity
  • Doesn’t have any smoke spillage
  • Easy and simple to use


  • The igniter needs to replaced often due to bad engineering

Buying Guide

Finding an economical way of warning your house is essential, given that the cost of energy keeps on going higher and higher. Pellet stoves offer a comfortable temperature while keeping the heat costs low and it can be a nice addition to your living room as well, which is why it is important to choose something that suits your taste.

There are some things you need to keep in mind before you go and buy a pellet stove.

Fuel Availability

You need to make sure that wood pellets are available near you otherwise your cost of fuel will increase since you most likely have to get them imported at a higher price.

The Stove Efficiency

A stove of a good quality is usually around 30000 to 50000 BTU and has approximately 70 to 90% efficiency.

The Pellet Hopper Capacity

If you’re going to be using your stove frequently throughout the day, having a small hopper will just be frustrating since you’d have to fill the hopper more often.

With a bigger capacity for your hopper however, you can get by through the day or even days at times depending on how big the capacity is.

Consider the BTU rating

If you don’t know the BTU you need to warm your apartment or home, you won’t be able to pick a good stove. Use an online BTU calculator if you’re unsure.

Manual or Automatic Ignition

With an automatic ignition feature, your wood pellets will light up on their own whereas with the manual ones you need to start it by lighting the pellets.

Final Words

If you don’t really have much knowledge about pellet stoves, it can get difficult to get the right one for your home. That is why we made it easier for you to choose one that fits your needs from a list of the best ones available!

You may also like to read: Best Cookware for Electric Coil Stove