Best Pie Carrier Reviews – Consumer Reports

Pies are basically like the life of any party. So, whether it’s for a glorious celebration or a grieving situation, pies have been in the hearts of Americans for almost every type of occasion.

But as easy as it is to make a pie, it’s not so simple when carrying it. It’s rather evident that you would need a suitable carrier for your pies when you’re transporting them. The best pie carrier can offer you a lot more than just serve as a container for your dessert

Choosing a pie carrier will be a lot easier after knowing all about their nifty features. So, this article will dig in a bit deeper and try to unveil the most feature-rich pie carrier that will serve your purpose. Here we go!

Top 10 Best Pie Carrier Reviews

While looking for pie carriers may seem like a relatively straightforward task for anyone, getting good value for your money can be challenging. We’ve listed a few of our top picks after analyzing the market. All of them have some unique features that make them stand out from the rest.

1. Picnic at Ascot Original Pie and Cake Carrier

Key Features:

  • Keeps food hot for long hours, especially casseroles
  • Top and bottom compartment accessible via dual zippers
  • Polyester canvas construction with a 600-denier rating

With unrivaled success in manufacturing pie carriers in the US for over 25 years, this niche product from Ascot will surely win your attention. The high-quality zipper top feature is handy when it comes to loading and unloading pies. You can even carry cupcakes, muffins, pastries, and casseroles in this polyester pie carrier.

It’s made from super-durable rugged canvas with a 600-denier polyester rating, making it look sleek while being sturdy. The top handle is a nice bonus for added accessibility. If you’re a party person who has a knack for carrying hot pies to people’s houses, this can be a great addition to your list of carry-on items.


  • Suitable for carrying pies and casseroles to a party
  • Fine-lined mesh interior sleeve with foil inside lid
  • Impressive design rugged mesh polyester that’s easy to clean
  • Comes in a choice of three colors – houndstooth, Navy, and Trellis Blue


  • No proper insulation grading
  • Not suitable for carrying cold desserts

2. Southern Homewares – 3-in-1 Plastic Cake Holder

Key Features:

  • 3-in-1 intuitive setup with two separate trays
  • Can also be used as a carrier for hard-boiled eggs
  • Designed as a kitchen appliance rather than a carry-on

Unlike other pie carriers meant for simply transporting food, this one has some exciting features to keep stored food fresh for a long time as well. Thus, the plastic pie carrier doubles as a food transporter and storage, making it perfect for pie-lovers who are on the go.

There are three separate containers for three different sizes to carry any dessert in the case. Be it cakes, cobblers, pies, cupcakes, or muffins – this pie carrier has got your back. The sturdy plastic used in making the product is durable and will last you a lifetime. Going for both food storage and pie carrying, this one is simply a bang for your buck. So get one of these products for your kitchen today if you’re a pie-o-holic.


  • Super-sturdy plastic build will last for many years
  • Can keep stored food fresh for a long time
  • Great as a gift for any pie-lover
  • Excellent value for the price


  • Not safe for the dishwasher

3. Zilpoo Plastic Round Food Storage Containers

Key Features:

  • Intuitive 2-pack setup with lid
  • Carrying capacity of 135 Oz.
  • BPA-free plastic used in the build

Food storage and pie carrying will feel like a breeze when you have this carrier with you. The 2-pack tier system is fit to carry pies that are up to 10-inches in diameter. You can also bring other desserts like doughnuts, cream-pies, bagels, and cookies with ease.

Don’t worry about any food degradation from its plastic build as the materials are entirely free from BPA particles. It’s practically safe to put in microwave ovens and dishwashers too. The design and dimensions are great for carrying it alongside your picnic basket to a party.

When it comes to the sheer versatility and superb value for money, it can’t get any better than this pie carrier from Zilpoo. It’s recommended for any pie lover who wants value for money.


  • Retains moisture well
  • Safe for use in microwave ovens and dishwasher
  • Can be stored inside the freezer
  • Fits 10-inch pies with no hassles


  • Can be slightly problematic when the inside vacuums
  • Lid can become somewhat loose after repeated usage

4. G & S Metal Pastry Bakeware Carrier

Key Features:

  • 12-inch non-stick bake pan with versatile heating options
  • Shatter-proof lid with premium steel construction
  • Inner side coated with Teflon Xtra non-stick lining

The ProBake Teflon Xtra NonStick is nothing more than a godsend for baking enthusiast pie lovers. You can simply bake your pie using the bottom lid and carry it on the same tray using the sturdy pie carrier basket. It’s that simple and intuitive!

The carrier is available in a wide range of color options and choices, including angel blue, kelly green, perfect pink, scarlet red, spring green, and white. So you can splurge on exploring the funky side of your taste along with functionality while carrying your baked goods in this carrier.

Ample room, along with uniform construction, makes sure that there are no hotspots in your baking too. For all the baking enthusiasts out there, who just want to keep the freshly baked pie texture intact, this pie carrier can be your best friend. The built-in lid can easily double as a baking pan, making it a perfect choice!


  • Suitable for carrying all types of pastries and baked goods
  • Oven-safe bottom doubles as a heating pan
  • Can also be used for baking & serving pizza
  • No BPA or PFOA used in the construction


  • Not suitable for storage inside the freezer
  • Lid is not air-tight or Snap-On

5. Agyvvt 10 Inch Portable Pie Carrier

Key Features:

  • Food-grade material used in construction
  • Collapsible handles with secure clamps for easy carrying
  • Additional trays for carrying eggs and cupcakes
  • Innovative 3-in-1 design for bakeries, cakes, and eggs

Get a load of eco-friendly goodness and support the environment when you get your hands on this wonderous product from Agyvvt. It’s a unique 3-in-1 setup pie carrier that’s simply perfect for any occasion or circumstance. You can do so much more than just carry pies in this container.

The food you store will remain fresh for a long time whole the collapsible handles with clamps secure the lid in place. Take it out on any grocery run or bake sale, and you’ll be sure to find its maximum utility.

The compact dimensions make it really good for traveling too. Just place the collapsible pie carrier in your car in a secure spot, and don’t ever worry about your pie while you drive. Don’t ever worry about environmental impact and say hello to recycling when you get this pie carrier for yourself. The food-grade PP material makes it all sorts of eco-friendly while still offering various functionality.


  • Entirely BPA-free and recycle-worthy materials
  • Zero environmental impact
  • Super-easy to clean
  • Good for carrying and displaying baked goods


  • Not suitable for the dishwasher
  • Can be a bit fragile

6. Progressive International Collapsible Party Carrier

Key Features:

  • Includes two reversible trays
  • Non-slip rings at the bottom
  • Patented design with unique features

Unlike other pie carriers that boast ultra-intuitive features and super-useful extra benefits, this one tends to take the opposite philosophy. The minimalistic pie carrier does one thing and one thing only – carrying a pie. But it just does it really well!

If carrying homemade pies was an art, Progressive International has basically reached perfection with this product. You can bring two pastries or two dozen deviled eggs simultaneously using the reversible trays in this dual pie carrier.

It’s also suitable for traveling, thanks to its non-slip rings. In addition, the trays fold up nicely to a collapsible compartment, making the carrier have travel-friendly compact dimensions too.

Minimalism rings best with this pie carrier. It’s simply a dedicated product to suit specific needs – carrying a pie. So get the best collapsible pie carrier for your collection today and be a hit at the next potluck party!


  • Can carry two pies with a 9-inch diameter or 28 deviled eggs
  • Safe for the dishwasher and easy to clean
  • Can keep food fresh for a long time
  • Nested design for trays to fold up inside


  • Dip on the lid can reduce internal storage space a bit
  • Safety clamps can get a bit loose after frequent usage

 7. Agyvvt 8 Inch Portable Round Cake Carrier

Key Features:

  • Multipurpose design for carrying & storing pies
  • Food-grade PP materials used in the build
  • Individual locking clips on both sides
  • A colored sliding handle on top with sturdy construction
  • Waterproof and shock-proof ticker cover for durability

Design aesthetics and functionality are the two principal design philosophies behind this unique pie carrier.

Thanks to its clear plastic cover and majestically decorated accents, the multiple pie carrier is a must-have for those who want to show off their baked goods and cakes. It’s also a good choice if you’re looking for a safe and suitable way to carry your pies.

The environment-friendly materials used in its construction are completely recycle-worthy, meaning you’ll leave zero impact on pollution. In addition, innovative ideas like solid locks and a stable base along with a high-rise dome make it an easy pick for anyone who’s looking for functionality.

As a bonus, the lid is resistant to any shock or damage so that your pie will remain intact inside. Say hello to exquisite food display and aesthetics as this pie carrier is one of the best in design. The transparent lid on top makes it a perfect choice for those who want to show off their food on the go. It’s suitable for bake sales and pool parties with food.


  • Safe for the environment and recycle-friendly
  • Transparent plastic dome lid for display aesthetics
  • Flat base with handle comes handy when displaying stored food
  • Very easy to clean by hand


  • Not safe for the dishwasher

8.  OXO Good Grips Glass Pie Plate with Lid

Key Features:

  • Borosilicate glass used in build to resist thermal shocks & cracks
  • BPA-free materials used in the lid
  • Vents on the top to allow moisture control

Elegance and functionality often don’t come hand in hand. But this pie carrier has proved that concept wrong and thrown it out the window. So get your hands on one of these products from OXO, and you can rest assured that your pie carrying needs are fulfilled.

With temperature-graded borosilicate glass and wide rims, this carrier has the most innovative features any pie-lover would ask for. You don’t have to worry about shifting your pie to a plate when reheating.

Just take out the best pie carrier refrigerated, reheat, and eat from the dish – it’s that easy! There’s even a moisture vent installed in the BPA-free lid to allow easy vapor passage. If you’re one to worry about frequently reheating your pie, this is the carrier for you. Effortlessly transition between various temperatures while keeping the pie quality intact and the carrier unharmed.


  • Can quickly transfer from fridge to freezer to microwave oven
  • Slosh-proof lid prevents spilling
  • Safe for the dishwasher & easy to clean
  • Wide rim for easy portability & grip


  • Fragile pans can get damaged by heat

  9. Agyvvt Portable Round Cake Carrier

Key Features:

  • Multi-dimensional design for baked goods and pies
  • Locking clips on the side with a handle on top
  • Food-grade materials used in construction

With diversified experience designing and manufacturing kitchen utensils, Agyvvt seems to have hit the jackpot with this one. Thanks to its ultra-affordable price point, the pie carrier simply knocks the competition out of the park. You can expect every good feature of a pie carrier in this product. It’s simply value for money.

This pie carrier has it all, starting with the multipurpose design, the transparent lid, and sturdy locking clips to the carrying handle on top. Thanks to its food-grade materials and sturdy construction, the product is destined to serve you for a long time as well. Get your hands on this ultra-affordable pie carrier if you’re the one to love a bargain. With such affordable pricing, it doesn’t get any better than this. The adequate features are enough to serve all your pie-carrying needs.


  • Great for carrying pastries or desserts
  • Transparent cover with uniform thickness
  • Shock-proof lid has a thick handle for easy portability
  • Locking clips are highly secure & maintain freshness for long


  • Can feel slightly cheap when using

 10. Sweet Creations Pie Carrier

Key Features:

  • 2-step lock with latches for stability
  • BPA-free plastic used in the build
  • Twisting lid design with air vent and handle on top
  • Dome-shaped cover

Sweet Creations means serious business when it comes to quality and affordability. The same is true for their innovative pie carrier. Although priced at an excellent margin, the product does not seem to compromise when it comes to features. For example, the dome-shaped lid with an air vent helps keep your pie fresh for a long time.

You can even store other baked goods like cookies and cupcakes inside the carrier to securely carry them in your car. The built-in handle also comes into convenience when you’re on the move with your pie in one hand. It’s made of BPA-free plastic and is super easy to clean too. Say goodbye to crappy quality that comes with cheap pie carriers, and this one will surely change your mind. So, get this product and add it to your kitchen collection today if you want a solid pie carrier for long-time usage.


  • Can fit pies with diameter up to 10 inches
  • Air vent helps to keep the pie fresh and free from moisture
  • Top rack is safe for the dishwasher
  • Handle buckles into the lid for compact portability


  • Can’t fit pies with a height
  • Vent holes don’t always work

Things To Consider Before Buying Pie Carrier

While you can see that there are numerous beautiful choices when selecting the best pie carrier, the process of making that curated list has not been so straightforward. We’ve gone through some serious testing of each of the products in our inventory, and here are the features that most stood out in our observation.

  • Size & Dimensions

Like any pie-lover would agree, these delicious desserts come in all shapes and sizes. But the most common form is a round one that’s about 9 to 10 inches in diameter.

So the best pie carrier should have an inner edge that can comfortably fit the standard-sized pie. Otherwise, your favorite dessert might end up getting damaged and broken while transporting.

Another critical dimension to look out for is the height or depth of the carrier. Although pies are made with varying depths, a suitable per carrier should contain a 2-inch capacity at the minimum.

  • Shape & Form Factor

Moving over to form factors, this is crucially important if you’re planning to utilize the maximum number of features from your pie carrier. But, again, classic designs are best for pie carriers, and it’s best to avoid any experimental ones.

Check to see if the design has a wide rim or sturdy handle for easy portability. A rippled edge can look good for aesthetics. But at the end of the day, flat rims are perfect for keeping the pie crust intact.

  • Build Quality & Materials

Pie carriers come in a variety of builds – glass, metal, and ceramic. Some variants are even ready for baking in the oven. So, think wisely about what type of material you’re choosing.

It’s good to get a non-stick one if you plan on baking your pie inside the carrier. But remember that it won’t be suitable for long-term usage as Teflon tends to fade away soon and get scratch marks.

Metal pie carriers are suitable for durability but are a bit on the heavier side. So, remember to factor that in for portability. Also, they are usually not dishwasher-safe.

A good balance between the two is plastic pie carriers. They are cheap, easy to clean and offer good features. Just remember to get one that’s made of food-grade materials and doesn’t harm the environment.

Things To Consider Before Buying Pie Carrier

What Is A Pie Carrier?

Simply put, a pie carrier is a specialized carrying container for pies. It has intuitive features like wide rims and carrying handles on the top that make it suitable for storing and carrying pies.

You can sometimes double the pie carrier as a carrier for other desserts like casseroles, cupcakes, and pastries. Some variants have special features to carry eggs too.

What Is A Pie Carrier

Why Do You Need A Pie Carrier?

Pie carriers are basically like the barrier between you and your pie getting rotten. We all know that homemade pies are susceptible to rapid degradation and can get spoiled very easily by bacteria. This is especially true when it’s left out in the open.

So to prevent that spoilage from happening, pie carriers can be a great solution. The intuitive design of these handy products makes it easy to preserve the pie’s freshness and keep it crisp for a longer time. And the inside of the pie will also be soft while maintaining a proper moisture ratio within its texture.

Another prime reason you might need a pie carrier is that it makes transporting the pie very easy. Avoid unwanted damage to the pie and mess in your car by storing it inside a pie carrier while moving.

Why Do You Need A Pie Carrier

How To Make A Fabric Pie Carrier?

Although not a popular way to go, you can also make your very own pie carrier by yourself. Follow this simple step-by-step guide for making a pie carrier out of fabric.

  1. Place a plate on your piece of fabric and cut a circular shape leaving two inches extra on the outer edge.
  2. Interface the fabric with thermal fleece and tote straps
  3. Topstitch the raw edges of the fabric using a sewing machine
  4. Place the tote straps on the stitched fabric and fold each strap on itself
  5. Line up the straps along the edge of the fabric and stitch around the whole setup

Here’s a follow-along video to help you along the way!

How To Make A Fabric Pie Carrier

Final Words

So that about sums up our take on what would be the best pie carrier for everyday use. We’ve tried to include some interesting insights into what makes each of the products in our list stand out. There’s also a nifty buying guide after that to help you make the right choice.

Don’t forget to check out the other excellent informative topics we have lined up after that. There’s one topic where you could learn to make a fabric pie carrier all by yourself. Hope you had a fun read!