Best Hand Crank Ice Cream Makers – Consumer Reports

While store-bought ice creams are still popular, many people want to avoid the added artificial and flavors. Also, many people love making ice cream with their families which is more like a tradition. However, there is not much to do when you have an electric ice cream maker. For all these reasons, many people prefer the traditional hand crank ice cream makers so they can make their favorite frozen treat without any hassle. However, ice cream makers, if not chosen properly, can pose multiple problems. For example, the usage of salt means the tub needs to be leakproof to preserve the flavor. As a result, one can feel quite confused when it comes to choosing an ice cream maker which may seem simple to inexperienced eyes. To help you choose, we have prepared a list of the best ice cream makers so you can choose one for yourself!

Buying Guide

Before you move on to buying an ice cream maker, let us take you through the features that you have to consider before buying the ice cream maker.


Before purchasing an ice cream maker, you should decide on the capacity of the tub. Many ice cream makers have a capacity of 1 quart only and are suitable for kids. However, the capacity can go up to 8 quarts which means you can make a big batch at once.

Though it means these makers demand more manual labor to churn the cream. So, think carefully about who is going to use the maker so you can choose something suitable for them.

Crank Design

Since the crank plays the most crucial role, you should choose something that has an optimum crank so one can churn without any inconvenience. Some cranks are difficult to move and require grease.

Try to avoid these and purchase something that has a smooth movement. The cranks should also be durable so they can function even after heavy duty and do not break easily. Otherwise, you have to replace the maker altogether.


Not every ice cream maker can deliver the perfect ice cream texture after 15-20 minutes of cranking. Some can even take 40-50 minutes which is really tiresome. So, check the machines that demand less time to make your ice cream.

Price Range

Not everyone consider it to be an essential feature, but if you’re on a tight budget, you should look for ice cream makers that are within your budget. If you choose one with amazing features but out of your range, you’ll end up being disappointed for not being able to buy it. Rather, look for one that is within your price range and also comes with all the essential features.

Additional features

The additional features depend entirely on you. Some people like ice cream makers that can even churn using electricity so they can save some hassle, some want a versatile ice cream maker for other frozen treats. So, check what features a maker has so that you can get the one you are looking for.




Check Price

Best Hand Crank Ice Cream Makers


Made of stainless steel

3-layer construction and insulation

Best Hand Crank Ice Cream Makers


Has a capacity of 6 quart

Features electric motor for quick ice cream making

Best Hand Crank Ice Cream Makers


Stainless steel mixer and shaft

Gears are made of zinc

Features an oak tub

Best Hand Crank Ice Cream Makers


Made of plastic and aluminum

Comes in 2 different colors: white and pink

Chef PS18 Under Cabinet Range Hood


Has a capacity of 6 quarts

Stainless steel parts and white oak container

ZLine ZLKB36

Elite Gourmet

Able to make 6 quarts of ice cream

Pine tub

Freezing canister made of aluminum

Kitchen Bath Collection STL-75

White Mountain

Comes in multiple capacities, 4 quarts and 6 quarts

Made of stainless steel

Zuhne iChorus 36-Plus


Has a capacity of 1.5 pints

The freezing bowl is made of aluminum

Perfetto Kitchen and Bath 36 in

Nordic Ware

Able to produce 1 to 1.5 pints of ice cream

Features an indicator for the temperature of freezing chamber

1. Immergood

Best Hand Crank Ice Cream Makers

The Immergood Stainless Steel Ice Cream Maker is one of the most popular ice cream makers in the market. This one is made of stainless steel and is a tub that has zero chance of leakage. The stainless steel body is prone to rust and durable. As a result, this maker can last from generation to generation.

The dasher is designed so you can churn your cream for the perfect consistency. There is no need for grease for smooth turning. So, don’t forget to check this one out!


  • Stainless steel sturdy body that can last for a long time
  • Triple action dasher for continuous folding of cream so you can achieve the perfect texture
  • Zero leaks which ensures no mixture between salt and ice cream
  • High capacity
  • Comes with a 3-year warranty


  • Price is on the higher side

2. Amerihome

Best Hand Crank Ice Cream Makers

Here’s another ice cream maker which tries to incorporate modern features with traditional one. While hand crank is quite convenient for outdoor, sometimes it requires much more time. To solve this problem, the Amerihome has added an electric motor so you can take a break from churning ice cream constantly.

This lessens the time to 30 minutes and ensures a beautiful texture. Overall, it’s a great one for people who would love something that offers a helping hand when it comes to ice cream making.


  • Integrated electric motor means quick freezing
  • Can produce ice cream within half an hour
  • Offers aluminum can with lid, sealed tub, ice crusher, and paddle for mixing
  • Comes with a manual that contains multiple ice cream recipes


  • The hand crank is not strong enough

3. Lehman’s Amish-Made

Best Hand Crank Ice Cream Makers

This particular ice cream machine is designed to satisfy your traditional soul. The beautiful white oak tub gives the vintage touch you need. However, when it comes to the various parts, they have used materials that ensure a long life.

The usage of manganese bronze and zinc alloy means it is safe from rust and corrosion. Moreover, the high capacity is great for serving a big batch of ice cream. So, if you want a simple ice cream maker like this, check this one.


  • A huge capacity of 8 quarts
  • Leakage-proof tub design that freezes cream quickly
  • Strong and durable, not prone to corrosion
  • Comes with a 5-year warranty
  • Simple and traditional-looking


  • Comparatively expensive

4. Donvier 837450

Best Hand Crank Ice Cream Makers

This one is best for people who want something that versatile and want to make frozen sorbet or yogurt, even drinks. This small ice cream maker is designed to eliminate the usage of salt and ice like the traditional makers.

Moreover, the aluminum tub can produce ice cream quickly and can be cleaned without any extra effort. So, check this one if you want something small to satisfy your cravings!


  • Multipurpose
  • The freezing bowl can be cleaned easily
  • No hassle of adding ice and salt
  • Only requires 15 to 20 minutes
  • Sleek and stylish
  • Comes with a 10-year warranty
  • Comes with numerous recipes


  • Low capacity